topic Re: Aggr Issue in QlikView

Aggr Issue

renjithpl — Mon, 21 Nov 2016 17:16:23 GMT

Hi All,

I have a table like below

Region	ID	BUU	BenefitFlag	Sales
America	A	ISS	0	100
America	A	BCS	1	200
America	A	HPN	0	500
America	B	ISS	1	300
America	B	TS	1	500
America	B	Storage	0	600

My Output table (Pivot) has two expressions.

1. =sum(aggr(sum({<BenefitFlag = {1}>}Sales), BUU, ID)) - Sales with benefits

2. =sum(aggr(sum({<BenefitFlag -= {1}>}Sales), BUU, ID)) - Sales without benefits

Output table when no selection made

Region	with_Benefit	without_Benefit
America	1000	1200

When I select BUU only (any one BUU)

eg. ISS is selected

Region	with_Benefit	without_Benefit
America	300	200

When I select More than one BUU for eg. I selected ISS and BCS

My output comes like below

Region	with_Benefit	without_Benefit
America	500	100

But my requirement is to get 600 in with_benefit and 0 in without benefit.

Region	with_Benefit	without_Benefit
America	600	0

Actually when you select ISS and BCS, look at the total of the BenefitFlag = 1 (0+1) for the ID A so that 100 also should come in with_Benefit bucket.

Any idea. ?

Thanks

Renji

Re: Aggr Issue

Vegar — Mon, 21 Nov 2016 18:52:24 GMT

Try to use indirect set analysis using P() and E()

Sales with benefits

=sum(aggr(sum({<Region = p({<BenefitFlag = {1}>})>}Sales), BUU, ID))

Sales without benefits

=sum(aggr(sum({<Region = E({<BenefitFlag = {1}>})>}Sales), BUU, ID))

Re: Aggr Issue

sunny_talwar — Mon, 21 Nov 2016 18:58:02 GMT

Would you be able to share some other expected results for other selection? I am guessing that ISS and BCS are not unique which require a particular kind of results. It would be helpful to understand the logic behind your expected result for different selections

Re: Aggr Issue

renjithpl — Mon, 21 Nov 2016 19:55:54 GMT

Here i am selecting ISS, HPN and Storage,

Inputtable after selection

Region	ID	BUU	BenefitFlag	Sales
America	A	ISS	0	100
America	A	HPN	0	500
America	B	ISS	1	300
America	B	Storage	0	600

So from the above table if you look at ID B, the sum of BenefitFlag is greater than 0 (1+0) and sum of BenefitFlag for ID A is equal to 0 (0 + 0).

if its greater than 0, then sum the sales (600 +300) and will be in the Sales_with_Benefit bucket, else, 500 +100 will be in the without bucket.

So my output should be like below

Region	with	without
America	900	600

thanks for your help..

Re: Aggr Issue

sunny_talwar — Mon, 21 Nov 2016 20:03:08 GMT

Try these

with

If(GetSelectedCount(BUU) = 0, Sum({<BenefitFlag = {1}>}Sales), Sum({<ID = {"=Sum(BenefitFlag) > 0"}>} Sales))

without

If(GetSelectedCount(BUU) = 0, Sum({<BenefitFlag -= {1}>}Sales), Sum({<ID = {"=Sum(BenefitFlag) = 0"}>} Sales))

Re: Aggr Issue

renjithpl — Mon, 21 Nov 2016 20:09:42 GMT

Bingo..!!