Solved: Two Product for a Date, always take highest Produc... - Qlik Community

sosl11 · ‎2024-09-05

Hi,

I am developing an App where I have some data that I need to transform in the load script.

Currently I am having the following issue:

I have extracted a small part of the data set and as you can see in the upper screenshot on the 11th of May 2023 I all of a sudden have two prices for that date (onwards it is always two prices available, where before the price for 1200 was always 0).

Now I would like to transfrom this data so that for 10/05/2023 it returns me only the row with ProductNr 1000 and price 1,274449. For 11/05/2023 I want it to return me the price for ProductNr 1200.

I need the specific ProductNr for that day to be 100 for anything before 11/05/2023 and 1200 for evertything after in this case, it might also switch to 1400 and 1600 (so there might be 4 prices for one specific date) further along the years. Basically it should always take the price where the ProductNr is the Max(ProductNr).

In which way can I achieve this? Thanks in advance.

ProductNr	Location	Date	Price
1000	King of Prussia	01/05/2023	1,274449
1200	King of Prussia	01/05/2023	0
1000	King of Prussia	02/05/2023	1,274449
1200	King of Prussia	02/05/2023	0
1000	King of Prussia	03/05/2023	1,274449
1200	King of Prussia	03/05/2023	0
1000	King of Prussia	04/05/2023	1,274449
1200	King of Prussia	04/05/2023	0
1000	King of Prussia	05/05/2023	1,274449
1200	King of Prussia	05/05/2023	0
1000	King of Prussia	06/05/2023	1,274449
1200	King of Prussia	06/05/2023	0
1000	King of Prussia	07/05/2023	1,274449
1200	King of Prussia	07/05/2023	0
1000	King of Prussia	08/05/2023	1,274449
1200	King of Prussia	08/05/2023	0
1000	King of Prussia	09/05/2023	1,274449
1200	King of Prussia	09/05/2023	0
1000	King of Prussia	10/05/2023	1,274449
1200	King of Prussia	10/05/2023	0
1000	King of Prussia	11/05/2023	1,274449
1200	King of Prussia	11/05/2023	1,21865
1000	King of Prussia	12/05/2023	1,274449
1200	King of Prussia	12/05/2023	1,21865
1000	King of Prussia	13/05/2023	1,274449
1200	King of Prussia	13/05/2023	1,21865
1000	King of Prussia	14/05/2023	1,274449
1200	King of Prussia	14/05/2023	1,21865
1000	King of Prussia	15/05/2023	1,274449
1200	King of Prussia	15/05/2023	1,21865
1000	King of Prussia	16/05/2023	1,274449
1200	King of Prussia	16/05/2023	1,21865

rubenmarin1 · ‎2024-10-16

Instead of:

If(Location=Peek('Location')

,Date(Peek('StartDate')-1

,YearEnd(StartDate)

)) as EndDate

It should be:

If(Location=Peek('Location')

,Date(Peek('StartDate')-1)

,YearEnd(StartDate)

) as EndDate

View solution in original post

rubenmarin1 · ‎2024-09-07

Hi, you can try reducing data using:

Inner Join (DataTableName)
LOAD
  Date,
  Max(ProductNr) as ProductNr
Resident DataTableName
Where Price <>0
Group By Date;

Or instead of inner join use left join to add a new field like "1 as isLastPrice" and use this flag in set analysis to get the last price.

sosl11 · ‎2024-10-02

Thanks for the suggestion Ruben, I managed to get a first result, now tho there is the possibility that actually we should not only look at the highest ProductNr because it is possible that it had already switched before from the higher to a lower one (in this case 1200 was ued in 2022 and not 1000). I suppose we have to include that it always look at which line has the Max(Date).

Table example:

ProductNr	Location	Date	Price
1000	King of Prussia	01/05/2022	0
1200	King of Prussia	01/05/2022	1,24
1000	King of Prussia	02/05/2022	0
1200	King of Prussia	02/05/2022	1,24
1000	King of Prussia	01/05/2022	0
1200	King of Prussia	01/05/2022	1,24
1000	King of Prussia	02/05/2022	0
1200	King of Prussia	02/05/2022	1,24
1000	King of Prussia	01/05/2022	0
1200	King of Prussia	01/05/2022	1,24
1000	King of Prussia	01/05/2023	1,274449
1200	King of Prussia	01/05/2023	0
1000	King of Prussia	02/05/2023	1,274449
1200	King of Prussia	02/05/2023	0
1000	King of Prussia	03/05/2023	1,274449
1200	King of Prussia	03/05/2023	0
1000	King of Prussia	04/05/2023	1,274449
1200	King of Prussia	04/05/2023	0
1000	King of Prussia	05/05/2023	1,274449
1200	King of Prussia	05/05/2023	0
1000	King of Prussia	06/05/2023	1,274449
1200	King of Prussia	06/05/2023	0
1000	King of Prussia	07/05/2023	1,274449
1200	King of Prussia	07/05/2023	0
1000	King of Prussia	08/05/2023	1,274449
1200	King of Prussia	08/05/2023	0
1000	King of Prussia	09/05/2023	1,274449
1200	King of Prussia	09/05/2023	0
1000	King of Prussia	10/05/2023	1,274449
1200	King of Prussia	10/05/2023	0
1000	King of Prussia	11/05/2023	1,274449
1200	King of Prussia	11/05/2023	1,21865
1000	King of Prussia	12/05/2023	1,274449
1200	King of Prussia	12/05/2023	1,21865
1000	King of Prussia	13/05/2023	1,274449
1200	King of Prussia	13/05/2023	1,21865
1000	King of Prussia	14/05/2023	1,274449
1200	King of Prussia	14/05/2023	1,21865

rubenmarin1 · ‎2024-10-02

Hi, the conditions are not clear, maybe you only need to remove the 0's before doing the join

sosl11 · ‎2024-10-15

Hi Ruben,

The data looks like this now:

ProductNr	Location	Date	Price
1200	King of Prussia	01/05/2023	1,16260000000000000000
1000	King of Prussia	01/05/2023	0
1200	King of Prussia	02/05/2023	1,16260000000000000000
1000	King of Prussia	02/05/2023	0
1200	King of Prussia	03/05/2023	1,16260000000000000000
1000	King of Prussia	03/05/2023	1,34937899999999990000
1200	King of Prussia	04/05/2023	1,16260000000000000000
1000	King of Prussia	04/05/2023	1,34937899999999990000
1200	King of Prussia	05/05/2023	1,16260000000000000000
1000	King of Prussia	05/05/2023	1,34937899999999990000
1200	King of Prussia	06/05/2023	1,274449
1000	King of Prussia	06/05/2023	0
1200	King of Prussia	07/05/2023	1,274449
1000	King of Prussia	07/05/2023	0
1200	King of Prussia	08/05/2023	1,274449
1000	King of Prussia	08/05/2023	0

As you can see this product started with product 1200 price (1,16) only being available where it then switched to 1000 (1,34) becoming available for product 1000 as of 03/05/2023). At this point it should only show me the price of 1000 as it is the latest availabe price (even though the ProductNr is lower, we can ignore that actually, it should always take the latest availabe price within the ProdcutNr). Then on 06/005/2023 the 1000 Price is not available anymore and the new 1200 price is available and should be used.

So we end up with only this:

ProductNr	Location	Date	Price
1200	King of Prussia	01/05/2023	1,16260000000000000000

1200	King of Prussia	02/05/2023	1,16260000000000000000


1000	King of Prussia	03/05/2023	1,34937899999999990000

1000	King of Prussia	04/05/2023	1,34937899999999990000

1000	King of Prussia	05/05/2023	1,34937899999999990000
1200	King of Prussia	06/05/2023	1,274449

1200	King of Prussia	07/05/2023	1,274449

1200	King of Prussia	08/05/2023	1,274449

rubenmarin1 · ‎2024-10-16

HI, but if the dates are the same ¿which one is the latest? If you want to retrieve the minimun ProdcutNr when the date is the same use Min instead of Max:

Inner Join (DataTableName)
LOAD
  Date,
  Min(ProductNr) as ProductNr
Resident DataTableName
Where Price <>0
Group By Date;

sosl11 · ‎2024-10-16

Hi Ruben,

That is exactly what my question was haha. Apparently rows were being created for both product in the database. I have gotten the dataset changed now to the following:

ProductNr	Location	Date	Price
1200	King of Prussia	04/08/2012	1.1624
1200	King of Prussia	31/08/2012	1.1552
1200	King of Prussia	19/09/2012	1.1654
1200	King of Prussia	30/09/2012	1.1625
1200	King of Prussia	18/10/2012	1.1626
1200	King of Prussia	31/12/2012	1.1626
1000	King of Prussia	23/01/2013	1.1518
1000	King of Prussia	31/01/2013	1.1626
1000	King of Prussia	01/03/2013	1.175
1000	King of Prussia	03/04/2013	1.1593
1000	King of Prussia	30/04/2013	1.1615
1000	King of Prussia	13/05/2013	1.1017
1000	King of Prussia	30/06/2013	1.1181
1200	King of Prussia	01/08/2013	1.1347
1200	King of Prussia	27/08/2013	1.1027

As you can see it is not possible for two Products to be available on the same date. Now the desired end table should have a Price for every date possible in the dataset. So I think the solution would be to create a EndDate based on Location/Date (so ignoring ProductNr). For example:

ProductNr	Location	Date	Price	EndDate
1200	King of Prussia	04/08/2012	1.1624	30/08/2012
1200	King of Prussia	31/08/2012	1.1552	18/09/2012
1200	King of Prussia	19/09/2012	1.1654	29/09/2012
1200	King of Prussia	30/09/2012	1.1625	17/10/2012
1200	King of Prussia	18/10/2012	1.1626	30/12/2012
1200	King of Prussia	31/12/2012	1.1626	22/01/2013
1000	King of Prussia	23/01/2013	1.1518	30/01/2013
1000	King of Prussia	31/01/2013	1.1626	28/02/2013
1000	King of Prussia	01/03/2013	1.175	02/04/2013
1000	King of Prussia	03/04/2013	1.1593	29/04/2013
1000	King of Prussia	30/04/2013	1.1615	12/05/2013
1000	King of Prussia	13/05/2013	1.1017	29/06/2013
1000	King of Prussia	30/06/2013	1.1181	31/07/2013
1200	King of Prussia	01/08/2013	1.1347	26/08/2013
1200	King of Prussia	27/08/2013	1.1027	27/08/2013

With the Range between Date and EndDate we can then create a line per date with that specific price that was valid. You know what I mean? How can I achieve this?

ProductNr	Location	Date	Price	EndDate
1200	King of Prussia	31/12/2012	1.1626	22/01/2013
1200	King of Prussia	01/01/2013	1.1626	22/01/2013
1200	King of Prussia	02/01/2013	1.1626	22/01/2013
1200	King of Prussia	03/01/2013	1.1626	22/01/2013
1200	King of Prussia	04/01/2013	1.1626	22/01/2013
		.
		.
1200	King of Prussia	22/01/2013	1.1626	22/01/2013
1000	King of Prussia	23/01/2013	1.1518	30/01/2013
1000	King of Prussia	24/01/2013	1.1518	30/01/2013
1000	King of Prussia	25/01/2013	1.1518	30/01/2013
1000	King of Prussia	26/01/2013	1.1518	30/01/2013
		.
		.

rubenmarin1 · ‎2024-10-16

Hi, to create the middle table you can do a sorted load by date descendant as use peek to retrieve the previous Date to create EndDate

DataWithEndDate:
LOAD
  ProductNr,
  Location,
  Date,
  Price
  If(Location=Peek('Location')
    ,Date(Peek('Date')-1
    ,Date // or YearEnd(Date)
  ) as EndDate
Resident DataTableName
Order By Location, Date desc;

And from this table you can create all dates with:

DataWithAllDates:
NoConcatenate LOAD
  ProductNr,
  Location,
  Date(Date+IterNo()-1) as Date,
  Price,
  DateEnd
Resident DataWithEndDate
While Date+IterNo()-1<=DateEnd;

DROP Table DataWithEndDate;

sosl11 · ‎2024-10-16

Hi Ruben,

Thanks this works for the small dataset with only one location. But once other Locations get added it does not seems to return correct values (EndDate always is the EndOfYear Date).

This you can just paste in Qlik Sense to see what I mean:

Pricing:

LOAD * INLINE [

ProductNr, Location, Date, Price

1000, King of Prussia, 23/01/2013, 1.1518

1000, King of Prussia, 31/01/2013, 1.1626

1000, King of Prussia, 01/03/2013, 1.175

1000, King of Prussia, 03/04/2013, 1.1593

1000, King of Prussia, 30/04/2013, 1.1615

1000, King of Prussia, 13/05/2013, 1.1017

1000, King of Prussia, 30/06/2013, 1.1181

1000, Berlin, 30/09/2012, 1.1017

1000, Berlin, 18/10/2012, 1.1615

1000, Berlin, 31/12/2012, 1.175

1000, Berlin, 23/01/2013, 1.1518

1000, Berlin, 31/01/2013, 1.1626

1000, Berlin, 01/03/2013, 1.1654

1000, Berlin, 03/04/2013, 1.1552

1200, King of Prussia, 04/08/2012, 1.1624

1200, King of Prussia, 31/08/2012, 1.1552

1200, King of Prussia, 19/09/2012, 1.1654

1200, King of Prussia, 30/09/2012, 1.1625

1200, King of Prussia, 18/10/2012, 1.1626

1200, King of Prussia, 31/12/2012, 1.1626

1200, King of Prussia, 01/08/2013, 1.1347

1200, King of Prussia, 27/08/2013, 1.1027

1200, Berlin, 04/08/2012, 1.1027

1200, Berlin, 31/08/2012, 1.1347

1200, Berlin, 19/09/2012, 1.1181

1200, Berlin, 30/04/2013, 1.1624

1200, Berlin, 13/05/2013, 1.1593

];

t_Pricing:

Load

DATE([Date]) as StartDate,

Location,

ProductNr,

Price

Resident Pricing

Order By [Date], Location desc;

Drop Table Pricing;

PricingEndDate:

NoConcatenate

LOAD

ProductNr,

Location,

StartDate,

Price,

If(Location=Peek('Location')

,Date(Peek('StartDate')-1

,YearEnd(StartDate)

)) as EndDate

Resident t_Pricing

Order By Location, StartDate desc;

Drop Table t_Pricing;

rubenmarin1 · ‎2024-10-16

Instead of:

If(Location=Peek('Location')

,Date(Peek('StartDate')-1

,YearEnd(StartDate)

)) as EndDate

It should be:

If(Location=Peek('Location')

,Date(Peek('StartDate')-1)

,YearEnd(StartDate)

) as EndDate

Two Product for a Date, always take highest ProductNr

Client Managed