Skip to main content
Announcements
Qlik Connect 2024! Seize endless possibilities! LEARN MORE
hic
Former Employee
Former Employee

As most of you have noticed – I hope – we have now released a new product.

Qlik Sense.

new_sense_overview-bottom_left.jpg

Qlik Sense is not just a new release of QlikView. Instead it is something different. But there are still so many similarities between the two products, so I thought it would be appropriate to dedicate a blog post to differences and similarities between the two.

Basically, the two products are two different user interfaces to the same analysis engine. This means that old scripts and old formulae will (almost) always work exactly the same way as before. (There are some smaller differences in that Qlik Sense uses libraries, and cannot always use relative paths for files.)

Hence, the two products both have the same Green-White-Gray logic; both use the same calculation engine; both have roughly the same response times; and you should use the same considerations for both when it comes to data modelling. This also means that many of the previous posts here on the Design Blog are just as relevant for Qlik Sense as for QlikView.

But the two products are still very different. And just as a parent cannot say that one child is better than the other, I cannot say that one product is better than the other. They are good at different things:

  • QlikView is a tool for situations where you want prepared business applications, i.e. applications created by developers who put a lot of thought into the data model, the layout, the charts and the formulae; and deliver the applications to end-users who consume the applications. We call this Guided Analytics. The end-user has total freedom to explore data, select, drill down and navigate in the information, and can this way discover both questions and answers in the data. The end-user is however limited when it comes to creating new visualizations. This type of situation will without doubt be common for many, many years to come.
  • Qlik Sense is a tool for situations where you don’t want to pre-can so much. Instead you want the user to have the freedom to create a layout of his own and in it, new visualizations; charts that the developer couldn’t imagine that the user wants to see. You want Self-service data discovery, which means a much more active, modern, engaged user. In addition, Qlik Sense is much easier to use when you have a touch screen, and is adaptive to different screen sizes and form factors. On the whole, Qlik Sense is a much more modern tool.

Finally, it is important to acknowledge that a piece of software is never ready. It evolves constantly:

Qlik Sense today is only the first version of something that will evolve further and get more features and functions as time goes on. Some of the features and functions of QlikView have not yet been implemented in Qlik Sense – there just hasn’t been time enough – but many of them will be implemented in coming versions.

Also QlikView is not yet a "final product". The product will be developed further, and most likely we will see some of the new functionality from Qlik Sense also in coming versions of QlikView. The goal is to use the same platform for both user interfaces.

With these two tools, we believe that we are well prepared for the future.

HIC

90 Comments
cleblois
Contributor III
Contributor III

I love what I see in QlikSense, looks like a great tool for users and ad-hoc BI.

What concerns me more is how the two solutions will be joined (or not) and sold by Qlik.

As a customer and responsible for Qlik in my company, I would expect that I can manage all users and jobs from a single console and that my licenses will allow my users to get access to both with a single license.

I'm not too keen on having to pay for 2 servers and 2 set of licences

CLB

711 Views
philip_doyne
Partner - Creator II
Partner - Creator II

Christopher,  HIC your views would be very welcome!

I have suggested to the product team that for situations like yours that you are likely to want to deliver apps to the same user from both Qlikview Server and Sense Server.    It does appear to me that you will not be able to install both server products on the same box.  I cannot imagine any large user who would migrate wholly from QlikView to Qlik Sense in a "big bang".   Indeed some of my clients have alreay twigged that the arrival of this brother(sister? - a discussion for another post perhaps) for QlikView will comple the family meaning that a wider cohort of users can be served more effectively.   This means that you really want one "Portal" or place to go for ALL your Qlik Apps (QlikView and Sense).     It seems to me that to open a QlikView App is essentially a URL in a browser and also to open a Sense app is also a URL in a browser.   The former is already well installed in the AccessPoint in QlikView Server.    It seems to my simple mind that it would be a relatively small job to extend the QlikView Management Console/AccessPoint to allow for a QlikSense Mounted folder so QlikSense Apps could be launched from the AccessPoint.  Clearly once you got there you would be in the Hub but maybe the hub could have an option to return to Access Point if it were so configured.   I guess this is a cross development team project and particularly the Sense team are very much focussed on their product.   It does, however,  seem to me to be an important issue for the likes of Christopher, a good few of my existing clients and probably many more.

711 Views
anderseriksson
Partner - Specialist
Partner - Specialist

I would say that a responsive design is highly overdue in the QlikView client. Not fully automatic since that could trash a well thought out design but using containers that can grow within limits when space is available like has been possible in web and Windows since the 90s. Letting tables grow in height for users that have extra vertical space. Also when we have two tables vertically letting the lower one stick to the upper one instead of leaving space between when there's only a few rows in the upper one.

0 Likes
696 Views
Not applicable

So can you tell us at the moment, whether there will an QlikView 12 version?

0 Likes
696 Views
Not applicable

QlikView v12 is coming next year!

696 Views
Not applicable

I'm looking forward to what QlikSence will end up looking in the near future. Merging the two products is never going to work, this will contradict the means for the users with a technical background and those without. Both will be frustrated. Obviously both products will work best in the environment suitable to the users (budget/technical ability/time frames/etc). Building on QlikSence and QlikView as individual products is a fair call. Keep it up.

0 Likes
696 Views
Not applicable

As I understand, QlikSence is QlikTech's response to huge and maybe slightly frightening success of Tableau...

As I see it - general concept, look & feel of both tools is quite similar. Sure, at the moment QlikSence looks like an infant compared to Tableau.

I'm oversimplifying, of course.

0 Likes
696 Views
evan_kurowski
Specialist
Specialist

You know, I've been kind of puzzled by that development... I don't know the Tableau product deeply, but from what I have seen it had a very polished presentation, and made some market headway by preparing pre-packaged applications.  Not a terrible approach by any means, but from what I understand.. it does not compare to the data transformation and application design possibilities of QlikView.  Can it really match QlikView in terms of capabilities?  Or am I missing something?

I mean, we can spend some effort making QlikView applications look prettier, but this seems to me like a case of form over substance.  Like an HR manager who's making hiring decisions because a candidate looks "hot".

696 Views
cleblois
Contributor III
Contributor III

I believe that user friendliness and design are key in BI.

I'm in IT, leading BI team. We spend 95% of our team efforts in building apps. Recently, we switched from a pure "who logs to what app" to "what are you really doing with what we develop for you". It was enlightening and depressing. A lot of our direct user are crunching figures for others and use QlikView or SAPBO to extract to Excel.

I believe that QlikSense can make a difference here (as Tableau is doing) and provide a platform that users can use for their own analyses.

It will also become a great platform for key users to prototype before a real undustrialization by IT.

735 Views
Not applicable

I'd be blown away if Qlik Sense or QlikView could connect to all of the major ERP databases.

0 Likes
735 Views