Skip to main content
Announcements
Qlik Introduces a New Era of Visualization! READ ALL ABOUT IT
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
kclayton1
Contributor III
Contributor III

P() function in QlikView 12

Did the p() function get removed in QlikView version 12 or higher?

Thanks.

Kevin

1 Solution

Accepted Solutions
oknotsen
Master III
Master III

I just checked some files made in QV11.2 with the P() function. Opened them in QV12 and the results look the same. No error.

So no, seems like it has not been removed.

Btw, there is no higher version since QV12.

May you live in interesting times!

View solution in original post

10 Replies
oknotsen
Master III
Master III

I just checked some files made in QV11.2 with the P() function. Opened them in QV12 and the results look the same. No error.

So no, seems like it has not been removed.

Btw, there is no higher version since QV12.

May you live in interesting times!
swuehl
MVP
MVP

What make you think it has been removed?

sunny_talwar

Its still there, use it all the time. I am using QV12

Capture.PNG

kclayton1
Contributor III
Contributor III
Author

I did not see it in the function list and the syntax checker throws an error.

oknotsen
Master III
Master III

Sounds like a new and an old bug.

Syntax checker has had problems with (more complex) Set Analysis since forever (I think; didn't check though I am sure for at least QV11.0). Not being listed sounds like a nice sweet new little bug.

May you live in interesting times!
sunny_talwar

I don't see any syntax error here

Capture.PNG

Might be due to something else you might have. Can you share your expression?

swuehl
MVP
MVP

Which function list are you referring to?

p() function can only be used within a set expression's field modifier, i.e. using set analysis.

kclayton1
Contributor III
Contributor III
Author

Good point. I had an error in my expression.  Thanks.

kclayton1
Contributor III
Contributor III
Author

Thanks. I was looking in the function list under the expression window.  I forgot that I would not find it there.  Thank you for your help.