Selections ignored when set analysis is used

[#1]

I have cut down my Qlikview application to its minimum and still cannot see why when I include  set analysis  {$} only, the existing selections are ignored.

Attached application DailySalesx.qvw has two charts which are the same except one has an expression =Sum(Period_01) the other =Sum({$}Period_01) . They should produce the same result. The one with {$} ignores  the year selection, always showing both years

I have built the equivalent from scratch testgenericsa.qvw and it works fine.

Any suggestions?

[Frank_Hartmann]

If you create a new sheet it will work

Strange behaviour !!!

[Frank_Hartmann · Accepted solution]

I figured out why its not working.

you have set up Alternate States. If you remove it then it will work on first sheet either

[ahaahaaha]

Hi,

Transferring object List Box to the default state solves the task (look attached file).

Regards,

Andrey

[#5]

Frank and Andrey many thanks. When I started working with Qlikview  I  inherited  applications and then used them as templates for subsequent applications propagating the problem. I was not aware of alternate state functionality so without unlimited time to play would not have solved it myself.