Qlik Community

QlikView Documents

Documents for QlikView related information.

Announcements

Breathe easy -- you now have more time to plan your next steps with Qlik!
QlikView 11.2 Extended Support is now valid through December 31, 2020. Click here for more information.

Qlikview Vs Tableau A comparison

ankit777
Not applicable

Qlikview Vs Tableau A comparison

 

There are many threads over the internet expressing different views and experience supporting each of the tools (Tableau vs QlikView) and criticizing the other one.

 

After doing several Qlikview and Tableau project, I have listed down some of the key difference between these two tools which I discovered under my understanding. Below are the listed differences/comparison. It would be nice of you to share your thought on same to enrich comparison sheet. This can help us in making choice between the two under different requirements and budgets for proposal and expressing our point of view for client prospects.

Special thanks to Sushil353 who has helped and provided expert comments in making this documents.

 

 

QlikView

Tableau

Those who desire strong visualization capabilities with BI Reporting.

Those who want to build real time visualizations on the fly, with little technical expertise required.

More commonly used as departmental vs. enterprise wide BI Solution

Commonly used for dash boarding purpose and rapid visualization.

Strong in financial services, insurance OEM version available for embedding in third party apps.

Server and online editions allow visualizations to be shared.

Combines visualization with in-memory BI tool and ETL engine

Dashboard simple to build, even for novice.

Easy to manipulate data from multiple sources on the fly.

Best for rapidly visualizing a single data set.

Single product for complete BI Solution

Dependent on ETL and DWH

Basic charts and visualization objects.

Charts are easy to build and has more visualization options

Gauge charts are available

No Gauge chart but bullet chart is easy to build

Powerful Straight and pivot table available

Not good for Tabular visualization. Seeks workaround for meeting complex requirement.

Longer learning curve

Easy to learn this tool

Maps needs workaround

Excellent in Maps

In-memory BI platform provides much faster analysis than traditional OLAP

Partial In-memory, Data extract and live connection fetch query result from hard disk/server.

Built-in ETL engine to transform disparate data sets into a common data structure.

In case data is residing in DB then view's has to be created by IT people.

Associative inference engine for uncovering associations in data sets.

Blending data from different sources can be difficult as no ETL to normalize data

Trigger and Actions are very powerful

Actions are available but has limited scope.

Easy to maintain objects and dashboard components.

Everything has to be developed as a sheet. For bigger application and more no of charts. Handling multiple sheets are not easy.

Global filters and global search is very powerful

Difficult to Implement global filter and no search option available

Extension objects are available for extra ordinary visualization

No support for such objects or charts.

Integrates with a very broad range of data sources including Amazon Vectorewise, EC2, and Redshift, Cloudera Hadoop and Impala, CSV, DatStax, Epicor Scala, EMC Green Plum, Hortonworks Hadoop, HP Vertica, IBM DB2, IBM Netezza, InforLawson, Informatica Powercenter, MicroStrategy, MS SQL Server, My SQL, ODBC, PAr Accel, Sage500, Salesforce, SAP, SAP Hana, Teradata and many more.

Integrates with a broad range of data sources including spreadsheets, CSV, SQL databases, Salesforce, Cloudera Hadoop, Firebird, Google Analytics, Google BigQuery, Hortonworks Hadoop, HP Vertica, MS SQL Server, MySQL, OData, Oracle, Pivotal Greenplum, PostgreSQL, Salesforce, Teradata and Windows Azure Marketplacea and many more.

Visualization speed depends on server RAM only.

Visualization speed depends on Source/DB speed and RAM of Machine

 

 

Comments
agni_gold
Not applicable

nice one got very interesting info from this doc     plz read every one

bill_markham
Not applicable

Is there a freebie version of Tableau for one to look at what it does ? 

[Not a time limited trial]

r_wroblewski
Not applicable

There is only a 14days trial available.

b_garside
Not applicable

Nice resource.

What version range would you say this comparison represents?  QV 11.xx  vs Tableau 8.0-9.0 ?

ankit777
Not applicable

Hi Brian,

Thanks. It would represent Qlikview 11.2 and Tableau 8.3

hrothenb
Not applicable

QlikView

Tableau

Built-in scripting and customization (including advanced layouts).

No scripting language for advanced transformations, calculations, programmable events or relating data.


Version history
Revision #:
1 of 1
Last update:
‎06-05-2015 01:57 AM
Updated by: