Do not input private or sensitive data. View Qlik Privacy & Cookie Policy.
Skip to main content

Announcements
Posting on Qlik Community is temporarily paused for some users. Thank you for patience and we'll update you soon!
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Oggy172
Creator II
Creator II

QS handling set analysis differently to QV

Hi,

I'm trying to migrate some reports (charts) from QV to QS.

On one, a median price list file, I have strange behaviour in QS.

I have a table, and when I add in any measure, I lose all results in the table - but on QV it works fine, I'm just trying a lift & shift.

With just the 3 dimensions, I get data (too much) - but when I add *any* of the 3 measures, it returns only a singular 'null' row.

 

With it being our pricing, it's not data I can really share - but hoping someone can see where it's going wrong. 

I've attached some fake files to aid with this

 

QV

 

Oggy172_1-1736862408864.png

 

Oggy172_2-1736862460427.png

Start Date:

 

 

 

 

min({<PL_Products.BlockedP={'N'},[Unit of Measure CodePL]={'*'}-{'FOC'},PL_Disc={'P'},PL_Item={'*'}-{'SSS'},[Start Date]= {"<=$(=min(PL_Startdate))"},[End Date]= {">=$(=min(PL_Enddate))"}>}[Start Date])

 

 

 

 

 

End Date:

 

 

 

 

max({<PL_Products.BlockedP={'N'},[Unit of Measure CodePL]={'*'}-{'FOC'},PL_Disc={'P'},PL_Item={'*'}-{'SSS'},[Start Date]= {"<=$(=min(PL_Startdate))"},[End Date]= {">=$(=min(PL_Enddate))"}>}[End Date])

 

 

 

 

 

Median Price

 

 

 

 

median({<PL_Products.BlockedP={'N'},[Unit of Measure CodePL]={'*'}-{'FOC'},PL_Disc={'P'},PL_Item={'*'}-{'SSS'},[Start Date]= {"<=$(=min(PL_Startdate))"},[End Date]= {">=$(=min(PL_Enddate))"}>}[PriceList Unit Price])

 

 

 

 

 

QS is the same

Oggy172_3-1736862624393.png

 

Oggy172_4-1736862674413.png

 

Labels (1)
1 Solution

Accepted Solutions
MatthewSmith
Contributor II
Contributor II

Try replacing '*' with "*" 

View solution in original post

3 Replies
Oggy172
Creator II
Creator II
Author

Expanded calculation QS:

Oggy172_0-1736866371150.png

 

QV

Oggy172_1-1736866461113.png

 

MatthewSmith
Contributor II
Contributor II

Try replacing '*' with "*" 

Oggy172
Creator II
Creator II
Author

Hi @MatthewSmith 

 

That appears to have fixed it, in that I get data - I will check over it's validity tomorrow - thank you so much!