Skip to main content
Announcements
Join us at Qlik Connect for 3 magical days of learning, networking,and inspiration! REGISTER TODAY and save!
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Peony
Creator III
Creator III

Issue with leftjoining loop results

Hi there. I have a table which columns should fliped from horizontal to vertical view. 
I have this:

let_code ENG GER
head_1 English Deutsch
head_2 Select your language Bitte wählen Sie Ihre Sprache
head_3 Customer Feedback Kundenfeedback


I need this:

let_code head_1 head_2 head_3
ENG English  Select your language Customer Feedback
GER Deutsch Bitte wählen Sie Ihre Sprache Kundenfeedback

 

So I create script that make this flip, but suddenly after I left join results I have data only for ENG, and GER has lost somewhere. Please help me to find mistake in code below:

Translate_TMP:
Load * Inline [
let_code,  	ENG,                   GER,                           
head_1, 	English,               Deutsch,                       
head_2,		Select your language,  Bitte wählen Sie Ihre Sprache,
head_3, 	Customer Feedback,     Kundenfeedback,               
];

Set vLanguage_Short_Name = 'ENG','GER';

Final: //"3_letters" as field name istead of "let_code" to avoid connection with Translate_TMP 
Load * Inline[
 "3_letters"
 ENG
 GER
];

For Each vLanguage_Short_Name in $(vLanguage_Short_Name)
Trace vLanguage_Short_Name $(vLanguage_Short_Name);

	For i = 1 to FieldValueCount('let_code')

		Let vField = FieldValue('let_code', $(i));
		Trace i $(i);
		
		Left Join (Final)
		Load Distinct
			'$(vLanguage_Short_Name)' as [3_letters],
			[$(vLanguage_Short_Name)] as [$(vField)]
		Resident
			Translate_TMP
		Where 
			[let_code] = '$(vField)'
		;

	Next i
	
Next vLanguage_Short_Name

Drop Table Translate_TMP;


And here is result I get:

Peony_0-1690298273789.png

I already despaired of finding the cause of the problem on my own.😭



Labels (2)
1 Solution

Accepted Solutions
vinieme12
Champion III
Champion III

Use below

 

 

temp:
load
* inline [
let_code,ENG,GER
head_1,English,Deutsch
head_2,Select your language,Bitte wählen Sie Ihre Sprache
head_3,Customer Feedback,Kundenfeedback
];

let vNoOfCols = NoOfFields('temp');
let vNoOfRows = NoOfRows('temp');

LEt vColName='';
For vCol = 1 to $(vNoOfCols)
  let vColName = FieldName($(vCol), 'temp') ;
  If  NOT '$(vColName)'='let_code' Then
	trace $(vColName);
    
    Let vfieldList='';
    Let vfieldName='';
    For vRows = 0 to $(vNoOfRows) -1;
    
    Let vfieldName = peek('let_code',$(vRows),'temp');
    LEt vfieldList = '$(vfieldList),'&'Peek(''$(vColName)'', $(vRows), ''temp'') as [$(vfieldName)]';
	
    
    Next vRows
    Trace $(vfieldList);
    
	Trace iterno();
    
    IF vCol=2 Then  // Assuming Column 1 is always let_code
    Main:
      Load 
      '$(vColName)' as let_code
      $(vfieldList)
      autogenerate(1);

    ElseIF vCol>2
    Concatenate(Main)
      Load 
      '$(vColName)' as let_code
      $(vfieldList)
      autogenerate(1);
    End IF
    
  End If


next vCol
Drop table temp;

 

vinieme12_0-1690450143529.png

 

 

 

Vineeth Pujari
If a post helps to resolve your issue, please accept it as a Solution.

View solution in original post

5 Replies
marcus_sommer

Within the most scenarios are joins not applicable within loops. The reason are the added fields because in the first iteration the new fields are added but in the second iteration the new fields aren't longer new else they become now join-keys ... which is usually not wanted or expedient.

Quite more relevant is the question why do you want to create such crosstable? Personally I would rather tend to a solution like:

t: crosstable(Language, Value, 1) load * from table;

and then you could access each value you want per set analysis, like:

maxstring({< Language = p(Language), let_code = {'head_1'>} Value)

vinieme12
Champion III
Champion III

Use below

 

 

temp:
load
* inline [
let_code,ENG,GER
head_1,English,Deutsch
head_2,Select your language,Bitte wählen Sie Ihre Sprache
head_3,Customer Feedback,Kundenfeedback
];

let vNoOfCols = NoOfFields('temp');
let vNoOfRows = NoOfRows('temp');

LEt vColName='';
For vCol = 1 to $(vNoOfCols)
  let vColName = FieldName($(vCol), 'temp') ;
  If  NOT '$(vColName)'='let_code' Then
	trace $(vColName);
    
    Let vfieldList='';
    Let vfieldName='';
    For vRows = 0 to $(vNoOfRows) -1;
    
    Let vfieldName = peek('let_code',$(vRows),'temp');
    LEt vfieldList = '$(vfieldList),'&'Peek(''$(vColName)'', $(vRows), ''temp'') as [$(vfieldName)]';
	
    
    Next vRows
    Trace $(vfieldList);
    
	Trace iterno();
    
    IF vCol=2 Then  // Assuming Column 1 is always let_code
    Main:
      Load 
      '$(vColName)' as let_code
      $(vfieldList)
      autogenerate(1);

    ElseIF vCol>2
    Concatenate(Main)
      Load 
      '$(vColName)' as let_code
      $(vfieldList)
      autogenerate(1);
    End IF
    
  End If


next vCol
Drop table temp;

 

vinieme12_0-1690450143529.png

 

 

 

Vineeth Pujari
If a post helps to resolve your issue, please accept it as a Solution.
vinieme12
Champion III
Champion III

Alternate script using Left Joins

 

temp:
CrossTable(lang,val,1)
load
recno() as key
,* inline [
let_code,ENG,GER
head_1,English,Deutsch
head_2,Select your language,Bitte wählen Sie Ihre Sprache
head_3,Customer Feedback,Kundenfeedback
];

For each key in fieldvaluelist('key')
if $(key)=1 Then
  Main:
  Load lang,val as $(key)
  Resident temp
  Where key=$(key)
  and lang<>'let_code';

ELSE
  left join(Main)
  Load lang,val as $(key)
  Resident temp
  Where key=$(key)
  and lang<>'let_code';

End if
// trace 
next key

Map_Names:
Mapping Load
key,val
Resident temp
where lang='let_code';
drop table temp;

Rename fields using Map_Names;

exit Script;

 

vinieme12_0-1690451536030.png

 

Vineeth Pujari
If a post helps to resolve your issue, please accept it as a Solution.
Peony
Creator III
Creator III
Author

Hey @vinieme12  Thank you for you help and ideas you shared. They help a lot!!!

Peony
Creator III
Creator III
Author

Hi @marcus_sommer  thank you for an explanation of the issue I faced. Will use this knowledge now.