Do not input private or sensitive data. View Qlik Privacy & Cookie Policy.
Skip to main content

Announcements
Join us in Toronto Sept 9th for Qlik's AI Reality Tour! Register Now
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
BA621858188
Creator
Creator

Diff between Job server or EC2 as Execution server

Hi Team,

My job is running on job server. I have scenario where I need to place the files either on Job server or EC2 and then later place on to S3 bucket?

Can anyone help me with pros and cons of using EC2 over job server? Also advantages of job server?

Labels (2)
1 Solution

Accepted Solutions
Jamesclary
Contributor II
Contributor II

Sure, I can provide you with a brief overview of the pros and cons of using EC2 versus a job server, as well as the advantages of a job server.

Pros and Cons of Using EC2:

 

Pros: EC2 provides a flexible and scalable computing environment that can handle a wide range of tasks, including file processing and storage. It allows you to choose your own operating system and software stack, and you have full control over the configuration of your virtual machines.

Cons: EC2 can be expensive to run, especially if you need to keep the virtual machines running 24/7. You are also responsible for managing the operating system, software stack, and security updates, which can be time-consuming and complex.

Advantages of a Job Server:

A job server is specifically designed for running batch jobs, such as file processing and data analysis. It provides a streamlined and efficient environment for running and managing these tasks.

Job servers are typically optimized for performance and can handle large workloads with ease. They also provide centralized management and monitoring tools, which makes it easier to keep track of your jobs and ensure they are running smoothly.

Job servers are often more cost-effective than running the same tasks on an EC2 instance, since they are optimized for specific use cases and can run more efficiently.

In terms of your specific scenario, the decision between using EC2 versus a job server will depend on a number of factors, such as the size and complexity of your files, the frequency and duration of your processing jobs, and your overall budget and resource requirements. It may be worth considering both options and doing a cost-benefit analysis to determine the best approach for your needs. My Sutter Online

 

 

View solution in original post

3 Replies
BA621858188
Creator
Creator
Author

@Richard Hall​  Please help here.

Jamesclary
Contributor II
Contributor II

Sure, I can provide you with a brief overview of the pros and cons of using EC2 versus a job server, as well as the advantages of a job server.

Pros and Cons of Using EC2:

 

Pros: EC2 provides a flexible and scalable computing environment that can handle a wide range of tasks, including file processing and storage. It allows you to choose your own operating system and software stack, and you have full control over the configuration of your virtual machines.

Cons: EC2 can be expensive to run, especially if you need to keep the virtual machines running 24/7. You are also responsible for managing the operating system, software stack, and security updates, which can be time-consuming and complex.

Advantages of a Job Server:

A job server is specifically designed for running batch jobs, such as file processing and data analysis. It provides a streamlined and efficient environment for running and managing these tasks.

Job servers are typically optimized for performance and can handle large workloads with ease. They also provide centralized management and monitoring tools, which makes it easier to keep track of your jobs and ensure they are running smoothly.

Job servers are often more cost-effective than running the same tasks on an EC2 instance, since they are optimized for specific use cases and can run more efficiently.

In terms of your specific scenario, the decision between using EC2 versus a job server will depend on a number of factors, such as the size and complexity of your files, the frequency and duration of your processing jobs, and your overall budget and resource requirements. It may be worth considering both options and doing a cost-benefit analysis to determine the best approach for your needs. My Sutter Online

 

 

BA621858188
Creator
Creator
Author

Thank you @James Clary​  I have one more issue in which I need your help.