QV11.20SR6: Bookmark with search expression does not work as in QV11

[Anonymous]

Hello!

Just send this to QT Support

We have an application where users store dynamic search Expressions in Bookmarks.

For example: search in the customer listbox for the expression in "=sum(Revenue) > 100000)". In QV11SR1 this expression was correctly stored in a Bookmark; in QV1120SR6 there are situations where - instead of the searchexpression - the actual selected customers are stored in the bookmark. This is a major issue, as the bookmark should always return a dynamic number of customers, depending on the expression!

Please follow the steps below! The erroneous behavior does not occur all the time, but with the specific steps below one can reproduce the issue!

Correct behavior in QV11.00SR1.

See video at http://jansolo.at/heldendaten/QV11SR1_CorrectBehavior.zip

- Open QVDeveloper 11.00SR1

- Open attached bookmarkSearch QV11SR1.qvw

- Search in Customer Listbox "=sum(Revenue) > 300000"

- Current Selection Box shows the SearchExpression

- Customer "D" is selected by the search expression

-Create Bookmark

- Clear all Selections

- Recall Bookmark

--> Current Selection Box shows Search expression

--> correct behavior

--------------------

Wrong behavior in QV11.20SR6.

See video at http://www.jansolo.at/heldendaten/QV1120SR6_WrongBehavior.zip

- Open QVDeveloper 11.20SR6

- Open attached bookmarkSearch QV1120SR6.qvw

- Search in Customer Listbox "=sum(Revenue) > 300000"

- Current Selection Box shows the SearchExpression

- Customer "D" is selected by the search Expression

- Create Bookmark

- Clear all Selections

- Recall Bookmark

--> Current Selection Box shows "D" instead of the search expression

--> wrong  behavior

--> if the data has changed in the meantime not only D but some other Customer should be selected by the search expression.

One can also see in the attached screenshot "CompareExportBookmarks.png" that QV11SR1 exported the bookmark with the dynamic search expression, while exporting the bookmark with QV1120SR6 the search expression is not in the export --> obviously the creation of the bookmark is wrong in QV11.20SR6

[Anonymous]

I was added to  bugID 68147 which is currently under investigation by R&D

seems more people have opened a case on this..

[daan_koster]

HI, did Qlik provide you a personal fix for this bug or are you like me in the waiting mode?

regards Daan

[Anonymous]

waiting mode, because it's not supercritical for our customer right now.

I haven't checked the SR8 Beta Release Notes yet, maybe it's in there..

[Anonymous]

hi!

seems like it's in SR9 Beta. It has a different BugId  - but the title sounds like my Problem:

63741 Advanced search expression is not restored from bookmark

Unfortunately I haven't had time to doublecheck it.

[Anonymous]

Latest answer from QTSupport including an easteregg in SR9:

Your Bug was closed as duplicate from Bug 63741: Advanced search expression is not restored from bookmark. Looks like this is more the same issue you are facing. The Bug is approved and is related to some Bug Fixes for the Advanced Search and happens only the Advanced Search string returns only one value selected. This could yet not be fixed completly, but there will be an easter egg with Service Release 9 (BC_SearchOnlyOneValue) to return to the old behauvior. In this case several other Bugs will ocure again ( 52772,53419,56197,56205,56240,59525).