Do not input private or sensitive data. View Qlik Privacy & Cookie Policy.
Skip to main content

Suggest an Idea

Announcements
This page is no longer in use. To suggest an idea, please visit Browse and Suggest.

Compose FDW automap should prompt when changing existing mappings

DWH2Go
Contributor III
Contributor III

Compose FDW automap should prompt when changing existing mappings

Compose automap is a handy button to press for 99% of landing to DW mappings.  There are usually a few columns that have to be mapped by hand though, and once mapped, should stick that way unless prompted to replace them.  Full scenario (actually encountered):

1. Landing has fields "F1" and "F1_ALT".
2. DW has field "F1_ALT".
3. Desired mapping: F1->F1_ALT done manually.
4. Additional columns added later to landing and DW.
5. Automap used to map new columns.  Result: Previous manual mapping silently replaced with F1_ALT->F1_ALT.

Automap should recognize different scenarios:

- Not mapped - automap ok
- Mapped like to like - no automap change needed
- Mapped manually - prompt user - ideally let user choose to preserve existing mappings or replace on a field level or for all changes.

 

Tags (2)
3 Comments
Tzachi_Nissim
Employee
Employee

Hi DWH2Go,

Thank you for your suggestion. So the suggested behavior is:

  • If no changes to existing mappings - continue with automap behavior.
  • If needs to change an currently mapped column - prompt the user.

This does make sense to me.

Thanks,

Tzachi

Status changed to: Open - Collecting Feedback
DWH2Go
Contributor III
Contributor III

That's correct

TimGarrod
Employee
Employee

Archiving due to age of idea and relevance (# of likes by community). 

Status changed to: Closed - Archived